Those who know me know that I love music with something bordering on obsession. I run a small record label, have a compact disc collection that is quickly approaching twelve-hundred CDs, and purchase and digest music at a rate akin to alarming (I am, at present, expecting no less than twenty-five discs in the mail from a variety of distributors and musicians; more, if you wish to count double- and triple- albums as two and three, respectively).
While I’ve only dabbled with crafting my own music, I’ve known enough musicians in my time and own enough discs to understand one thing above all others: artists deserve compensation for what they do. Now, think what you may, but this isn’t going to be a baseless tirade against mp3s (I’m all for them, as this post shall make explicit; mp3s don’t kill good music, they promote it). Rather, this post, a revision of an essay I posted to the Tumorlist nearly two years ago, is a dissertation on why musical art for which a demand exists must not be allowed to rot, half-remembered, in the purgatory that is an out-of-print state.
Some time ago I made the decision to pursue and purchase each release by Les Joyaux De La Princesse, be it current or long deleted. At the time that I vowed to find and treasure each release by Mr. Erik Konofal, I had but the loosest sense of how financially costly my endeavour would be. However, my utter fascination with the project’s carefully conceived orchestral drones and brilliantly aesthetic packaging appealed far too much to my auditory sense and personal historical interests to be denied.
Had I only known then what it was that I was stepping into. Tracking down, let alone purchasing copies of Les Joyaux De La Princesse items has proven to be a task well beyond my financial means and, most likely, beyond those of most individuals. Perhaps this applies to but a few of you, but I feel that I speak for many people when I lament the loss of beautiful releases, such as those written by Erik Konofal, to the sands of time — meaning, older releases are available only to those with pockets deep enough to afford them due to their respective rarity.
Mp3s have proven to be a source of satisfaction, albeit limited, in my pursuit. Fortunately for me I am blessed in having high bitrate encodings of the majority of Les Joyaux De La Princesse’s discography. Unfortunately, even mp3s of high quality fall victim to the shortcomings of audio compression and lack the exquisite packaging typical of each release. Much to my chagrin, it appears that mp3s are to be my only source of pleasure in regards to Les Joyaux De La Princesse due to personal financial restraint. I am eager to help support Erik Konofal’s musical endeavours through the purchasing of his discography, but buying through a private channel such as eBay is not only frighteningly expensive, it does nothing to lend any degree of financial support to him.
It is my hope that one day, perhaps soon, Les Joyaux De La Princesse himself will allow his out-of-print rarities to be republished. It is with growing dismay that I see items related to the project sell for hundreds of dollars on eBay, knowing that not a single penny of the sale is going to the man responsible for the music being sold. With each passing day and with each Les Joyaux De La Princesse item I see on the auction circuit I hope desperately, though most certainly not altruistically, that Erik’s material will see wide-spread availability in the immediate future. In the meantime, the free market will continue to prey on those eager to own copies of the material for it’s own personal gain.
A further example of this can be seen in some of Coil’s recent releases. Coil, prolific as ever despite — or perhaps in spite of — a twenty-plus year career, have been touring heavily in Europe and peddling concert-only CD-Rs at their shows. This is a wonderful opportunity for those fans living in Europe who are fortunate enough to live near the venue, but an unfortunate consequence of living in North America, as I do, is that I’ve — like the vast majority of North American fans — never had (and likely never will) the pleasure of witnessing a live Coil show, nor perusing their merchandise booths, nor making their affable acquintance either before or after the show. This cuts me and many others off from the variety of concert-only releases pressed, though I admit that I’ve managed to obtain copies of both the original Remote Viewer and the original ANS.
However, each of the aforementioned items was obtained through eBay, wherein I was forced to compete against other like-minded — and likely geographically isolated — fans, through the power of the dollar, of which Coil never saw a cent. This is my biggest objection to musicians allowing material to languish in a deleted state; where a demand exists, it should be filled. It is a most unfortunate state of affairs when certain people can turn a gross profit by attending a concert, purchasing at least five copies of a release, and selling them immediately to less fortunate fans.
Coil, however, has wised up to this. In response to rampant demand, they’ve opted to made available the latest tour CD-R through their website, promised the re-release of previous concert-only discs in a revised and expanded format, and overall, bent over backwards to best accomdate their decades of fandom. Personally, having the option to purchase Black Antlers directly from Thresholdhouse, knowing that it is Coil reaping the benefit… I am all too happy to do so, knowing that the entity responsible for the music in question is profiting through their art. It is a wondrous thing that Coil has responded in this manner, and I suppose that certain people who have played the auction circuit to their personal advantage are partially to thank for this — especially if the band’s move is in direct response to it — but I cannot help but pity the fans (to think, I nearly typed “poor fans”, though that would hardly be prudent given what some of those discs sold for, now would it?) who shelled out small fortunes for this disc.
Bottomline, I am dissatified with the availability of certain releases by certain musicians. In all instances I am willing to support the source of the material, the artist, and am unable to. Market demand, such as the high bids, the number of bidders and the price frequently fetched on the auction circuit translates to high demand for the material. This could be extended beyond Les Joyaux De La Princesse to bands such as Genocide Organ, Der Blutharsch, and many, many more. It’s interesting to note that some bands beyond Coil, such as Haus Arafna, Navicon Torture Technologies, Propergol and Slogun are having — or have had — rare items reprinted and remastered for release — rare items that have fetched top-dollar on eBay and will soon see wide-spread distribution, because the demand has been so great.
I suppose then that I ask of you, gentlemen and ladies, why can’t Les Joyaux De La Princesse be more like Navicon Torture Technologies? Why can’t Genocide Organ be more like Coil? What reasons does a musician have for not republishing out-of-print items, particularily when there is such a clear and obvious demand for it?
ADDENDUM: I’m likely to revise this post, for clarity as well as clerical reasons, rounding it out with a handful of links, perhaps include further eBay analysis (of Les Joyaux De La Princesse), as well as the possible inclusion of a paragraph acknowledging that, yes, I know that these prices are being paid because the person bidding has chosen to do so.